St. Augustine, Florida, is not only the oldest city in the United States but also one of the most charming culinary destinations on the East Coast. This historic town offers a blend of rich culture, coastal scenery, and a diverse food scene that appeals to every kind of palate. From freshly caught seafood and Southern comfort food to fine dining experiences and hidden local gems, the best restaurants in St. Augustine deliver memorable flavors in unique settings. Whether you’re visiting for the first time or a longtime local, exploring St. Augustine’s restaurants is a journey worth taking.
Seafood Restaurants in St. Augustine
Given its coastal location, it’s no surprise that St. Augustine is known for exceptional seafood. Restaurants here often serve locally sourced fish, shrimp, oysters, and more, often with a Southern or Caribbean twist.
O’Steen’s Restaurant
O’Steen’s is a local institution, beloved for its fried shrimp, hushpuppies, and Southern-style sides. Despite its modest setting and no-reservations policy, the food speaks for itself. Their signature Minorcan clam chowder is also a must-try, with a flavorful kick from the datil pepper native to the region.
Catch 27
Catch 27 specializes in locally caught fish and uses fresh, seasonal ingredients to elevate each dish. The menu includes shrimp and grits, fish tacos, and blackened catch-of-the-day entrees. The ambiance is cozy yet modern, making it perfect for both casual lunches and romantic dinners.
Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille
Located in a beautiful historic building, Harry’s brings New Orleans flavor to the St. Augustine waterfront. With Creole and Cajun-inspired dishes like jambalaya, crawfish étouffée, and red beans and rice, it’s a favorite among visitors looking for bold flavors and a scenic patio view.
Romantic and Fine Dining Restaurants
St. Augustine also boasts an impressive array of fine dining establishments that offer elegant cuisine in charming and intimate settings. These spots are ideal for special occasions or a refined night out.
Collage Restaurant
Often ranked among the best restaurants in St. Augustine, Collage is known for its romantic atmosphere and globally inspired cuisine. Dishes are prepared with precision and beautifully presented. The beef tenderloin, lobster ravioli, and Chilean sea bass are popular menu items.
The Raintree Restaurant
Set in a restored Victorian home, The Raintree offers a mix of Mediterranean and American cuisine with a touch of sophistication. Guests can dine on a candlelit patio or inside a cozy dining room while enjoying dishes like steak au poivre, duck breast, or escargot appetizers.
Llama Restaurant
For something different, Llama brings authentic Peruvian cuisine to St. Augustine with a modern twist. Chef Marcel Vizcarra crafts dishes like ceviche, lomo saltado, and quinoa-stuffed peppers in a small but elegant space that focuses on a personalized dining experience.
Family-Friendly and Casual Dining
Traveling with kids or looking for something more laid-back? St. Augustine has a wide selection of family-friendly restaurants with hearty menus, quick service, and fun environments that make dining easy and enjoyable for everyone.
Sunset Grille
Located on A1A Beach Boulevard, Sunset Grille offers a large menu with something for everyone. Their shrimp nachos are legendary, and the beachy vibes make it a great stop after a day on the sand. It’s a casual but dependable option with generous portions and friendly service.
Beachcomber Restaurant
Literally located on the beach, Beachcomber is perfect for families and beachgoers who want to enjoy good food in flip-flops. It’s known for burgers, seafood baskets, and relaxed outdoor seating where kids can play in the sand while adults unwind with a drink.
Mojo Old City BBQ
If your group is craving barbecue, Mojo’s delivers smoky ribs, brisket, pulled pork, and all the classic sides. The rustic, music-themed decor adds to the Southern experience, and the casual vibe makes it a hit with groups and families alike.
Breakfast and Brunch Hotspots
The best restaurants in St. Augustine aren’t limited to lunch and dinner. The city also has some standout spots for breakfast and brunch, serving everything from classic pancakes to inventive omelets and healthy bowls.
Maple Street Biscuit Company
This popular breakfast spot is famous for its flaky, buttery biscuits and creative takes on Southern breakfast classics. Try the ‘Squawking Goat’ biscuit sandwich or indulge in their house-made sausage gravy over warm biscuits. With fast-casual service, it’s ideal for a quick and satisfying meal.
The Blue Hen Café
Located in the Lincolnville Historic District, The Blue Hen is a charming neighborhood cafe serving hearty breakfasts and brunch. Their cinnamon roll pancakes and veggie hash are top choices, and the cheerful atmosphere makes it a morning favorite for both locals and tourists.
Georgie’s Diner
This retro-style diner blends classic American fare with Greek influences. Whether you want a stack of pancakes, a hearty omelet, or something Mediterranean like spanakopita, Georgie’s provides a fun and nostalgic dining experience.
Unique and Hidden Gems
While popular spots draw the crowds, some of the best restaurants in St. Augustine are tucked away in quieter corners of town. These hidden gems offer local charm, creative menus, and unforgettable flavors.
- The Floridian: Specializing in innovative Southern fare for omnivores, herbivores, and locavores, this eco-conscious restaurant uses fresh, local ingredients and has a unique take on Southern cuisine with plenty of vegan and vegetarian options.
- Preserved Restaurant: Set in a historic building in Lincolnville, Preserved offers upscale Southern dishes in a serene setting. The menu features items like crispy pork belly, fried green tomatoes, and duck confit, highlighting the best of Southern tradition and fine cooking.
- Back 40 Urban Café: A colorful and eclectic eatery serving international fusion dishes with flair. It’s a great place for something unexpected, like a Jamaican jerk chicken bowl, Thai peanut noodles, or Cuban-style sandwiches.
The best restaurants in St. Augustine reflect the city’s rich heritage, coastal location, and creative culinary spirit. From historic haunts to contemporary kitchens, there’s no shortage of delicious experiences to enjoy. Whether you’re craving fresh seafood, Southern classics, fine dining, or a relaxed family meal, this vibrant town offers something for every taste. Exploring the St. Augustine food scene is not just about eating it’s about savoring the stories, flavors, and charm that make the city truly unique. Take your time, try something new, and discover why St. Augustine remains one of Florida’s top destinations for food lovers.